Most people walk into a lawyer's office, get overwhelmed by legal jargon, and sign a retainer agreement without asking the right questions. Then three months and $8,000 later, they realize they hired the wrong person. Here are the 15 questions that protect you from that mistake—and what the answers should sound like.
About Their Experience
1. "How many cases like mine have you handled?"
Why it matters: You want someone who has handled your specific type of case recently, not someone who "dabbles" in your area.
Good answer: "I've handled about 30 custody modifications in the last two years." Bad answer: "I handle all kinds of family law matters."
2. "What were the outcomes?"
Why it matters: Experience without results is just practice. You want to know their track record.
Good answer: "Most settle favorably. I took two to trial last year and won both." Bad answer: "Every case is different" (without specifics).
3. "Who will actually be working on my case?"
Why it matters: At many firms, the senior partner sells you, then a junior associate does the work. That's not always bad—but you should know.
Good answer: "I'll handle strategy and court appearances. My associate handles research and document drafting, and I review everything." Bad answer: Vague deflection.
About Your Case
4. "What's your honest assessment of my case?"
Why it matters: A lawyer who only tells you good news is either inexperienced or selling you.
Good answer: "Your case has strong points—here's why. But here are the challenges we'd need to overcome." Red flag: "You have a slam dunk. This is going to be easy."
5. "What's the likely range of outcomes?"
Why it matters: You need realistic expectations, not promises.
Good answer: "Best case, we get X. Worst case, Y. Most likely, something in between." Red flag: "I guarantee we'll get you $X."
6. "What's the likely timeline?"
Why it matters: Legal matters always take longer than you expect. Get a realistic estimate upfront.
Good answer: "Cases like this typically take 6-12 months, depending on the other side's cooperation." Bad answer: "We'll have this wrapped up in no time."
7. "What are my alternatives to going to court?"
Why it matters: A good lawyer explores mediation, negotiation, and settlement before litigation. A lawyer who jumps straight to "we'll sue" may be prioritizing billable hours over your best interest.
About Money
8. "What's your fee structure and total cost estimate?"
Why it matters: The #1 source of lawyer-client disputes is billing. Pin this down before signing anything.
Good answer: A clear written breakdown of hourly rate/flat fee, retainer amount, and estimated total range. Red flag: "We'll figure it out as we go."
9. "What costs are separate from your fee?"
Why it matters: Filing fees, expert witnesses, deposition costs, and copying charges can add thousands to your bill. These are often on top of the attorney's fee.
Good answer: An itemized list of likely additional costs.
10. "How do you bill for phone calls and emails?"
Why it matters: Many lawyers bill in 6-minute increments. A 2-minute email check could cost you $30-$50. Know the policy.
Good answer: "I bill in 6-minute increments for calls and emails. Quick emails under one minute aren't billed."
11. "Can I get a detailed bill each month?"
Why it matters: You should receive itemized statements showing exactly what work was done and how long it took. This keeps everyone honest.
Good answer: "Absolutely, we send detailed monthly invoices." Red flag: Any hesitation.
About Communication
12. "How quickly do you typically respond to client communications?"
Why it matters: Poor communication is the #1 complaint people have about lawyers. Set expectations now.
Good answer: "I respond to emails within 24 hours and return calls the same business day." Bad answer: "I'm very busy but I'll try my best."
13. "Will I be updated proactively, or do I need to call for updates?"
Why it matters: Some lawyers only reach out when they need something from you. You should be kept in the loop on all developments.
Good answer: "I send written updates after every significant development and check in at least once a month even if nothing has changed."
About the Engagement
14. "What happens if I'm unhappy with your representation?"
Why it matters: You always have the right to fire your lawyer. But understand the financial implications.
Good answer: "You can terminate at any time. You'd owe for work completed, and I'd promptly transfer your file to new counsel."
15. "Can I see the retainer agreement before deciding?"
Why it matters: Never sign a retainer agreement on the spot. Take it home, read it carefully, and sleep on it.
Good answer: "Of course. Take your time reviewing it." Red flag: Any pressure to sign immediately.
Bonus: Trust Your Gut
Beyond these questions, pay attention to how the lawyer makes you feel. Did they listen? Did they explain things clearly? Did they seem genuinely interested in your problem? A lawyer can have perfect credentials but terrible communication—and communication is what makes or breaks the attorney-client relationship.
Print this list, bring it to your consultation, and don't be embarrassed to read directly from it. Any lawyer worth hiring will respect you for being thorough.
Ready to Find the Right Legal Service?
Compare the top-rated online legal platforms and get the help you need in minutes.
Compare Top Legal Services →